Skip to main content

Why your protagonist stays stuck at the start

Your protagonist stays stuck because The Lie has actually paid them, and their excuse for staying is a trade a fair listener would half accept.

Your protagonist's false belief about themselves isn't stupid. It's been working, and that's why they won't let it go.
In Toy Story, Woody believes his worth depends on being Andy's favorite toy. For years that belief has kept him on the bed and in the light.
A belief like Woody's is what StoryDNA calls The Lie: something false your protagonist believes about themselves, taken on to manage a fear. The Lie isn't a mistake they haven't noticed. It pays.
So be honest about what The Lie has bought your protagonist: safety, success, status. Whatever it bought is the price they'd pay to give it up.
On top of what The Lie pays, your protagonist has an excuse: the story they tell themselves about why they can't change. It sounds like wisdom, realism or caution.
Holly Golightly in Breakfast at Tiffany's tells herself that running before anyone can cage her is just staying free. That excuse borrows from her real love of freedom, so a fair listener would half agree.
Max in Collateral has driven a cab for twelve years and still calls it temporary. He has a plan for his own limo company that he never starts. He isn't stuck because of who he is. He's stuck because of who he thinks he is.
The excuse a person gives for staying the same is usually a reasonable trade, which is exactly why it holds.
So write your protagonist's excuse the way they'd say it to a friend. If a fair listener wouldn't half agree, The Lie isn't paying enough to keep them stuck.
Come build The Lie in StoryDNA. The Excuse Story question asks what your protagonist tells themselves to stay stuck. It's one of 977 questions StoryDNA asks about your story.

Your protagonist's false belief about themselves isn't stupid. It's been working, and that's why they won't let it go.

In Toy Story, Woody believes his worth depends on being Andy's favorite toy. For years that belief has kept him on the bed and in the light.

A belief like Woody's is what StoryDNA calls The Lie: something false your protagonist believes about themselves, taken on to manage a fear. The Lie isn't a mistake they haven't noticed. It pays.

So be honest about what The Lie has bought your protagonist: safety, success, status. Whatever it bought is the price they'd pay to give it up.

On top of what The Lie pays, your protagonist has an excuse: the story they tell themselves about why they can't change. It sounds like wisdom, realism or caution.

Holly Golightly in Breakfast at Tiffany's tells herself that running before anyone can cage her is just staying free. That excuse borrows from her real love of freedom, so a fair listener would half agree.

Max in Collateral has driven a cab for twelve years and still calls it temporary. He has a plan for his own limo company that he never starts. He isn't stuck because of who he is. He's stuck because of who he thinks he is.

The excuse a person gives for staying the same is usually a reasonable trade, which is exactly why it holds.

So write your protagonist's excuse the way they'd say it to a friend. If a fair listener wouldn't half agree, The Lie isn't paying enough to keep them stuck.

Want to work through this in your own story?

Come build The Lie in StoryDNA. The Excuse Story question asks what your protagonist tells themselves to stay stuck. It's one of 977 questions StoryDNA asks about your story.

We also posted this one on Instagram and Facebook.

More on this topic

See every insight on this topic