Skip to main content

Why one right choice at the end doesn't prove your theme

A protagonist's climactic choice on its own is consistent with your story's position without ever establishing it, because a second position would explain the same choice equally well.

Your protagonist making the right choice at the end doesn't prove your story's point. It just fits it.
Here's a test. Write down what your story argues. Then write a different argument and ask whether it explains your ending just as well.
If it does, your ending didn't prove anything. It just showed someone doing something admirable.
Proof works by ruling other explanations out. And you can't rule out an explanation if nobody in your story is voicing it.
StoryDNA builds six characters around your protagonist, and four of them are there for this. Each one keeps a different explanation alive, so when your protagonist changes, only one explanation is left standing.
In Schindler's List, Stern says out loud that Schindler is just a profiteer. That's why Schindler spending his fortune down to nothing means something at the end.
You know someone has really changed when there's no other way to explain what they just did.
So write the second explanation for your own ending, the one you didn't mean. Then find the character who rules it out. If nobody does, that's the character you're missing.
Come try StoryDNA free. It's built from hundreds of stories that worked, taken apart question by question, and this is one of the questions it asks about yours.

Your protagonist making the right choice at the end doesn't prove your story's point. It just fits it.

Here's a test. Write down what your story argues. Then write a different argument and ask whether it explains your ending just as well.

If it does, your ending didn't prove anything. It just showed someone doing something admirable.

Proof works by ruling other explanations out. And you can't rule out an explanation if nobody in your story is voicing it.

StoryDNA builds six characters around your protagonist, and four of them are there for this. Each one keeps a different explanation alive, so when your protagonist changes, only one explanation is left standing.

In Schindler's List, Stern says out loud that Schindler is just a profiteer. That's why Schindler spending his fortune down to nothing means something at the end.

You know someone has really changed when there's no other way to explain what they just did.

So write the second explanation for your own ending, the one you didn't mean. Then find the character who rules it out. If nobody does, that's the character you're missing.

Want to work through this in your own story?

Come try StoryDNA free. It's built from hundreds of stories that worked, taken apart question by question, and this is one of the questions it asks about yours.

We also posted this one on Instagram and Facebook.

More on this topic

See every insight on this topic